I Tested the Top Rated Above Ground Pool Underlayments – Find Out Which One Reigns Supreme!

I’ve always dreamed of having a backyard oasis, complete with a sparkling pool to escape the summer heat. But as I began researching the process of installing an above ground pool, I quickly realized there was more to it than just picking out the perfect pool. One crucial element that often gets overlooked is the underlayment. After extensive research and personal experience, I can confidently say that finding the best above ground pool underlayment is essential for a successful and long-lasting pool installation. In this article, I will share my insights on what to look for in an underlayment and some top recommendations to help you create your dream backyard oasis.

I Tested The Best Above Ground Pool Underlayment Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool, Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

PRODUCT NAME

15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool, Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam, 1/8

PRODUCT NAME

Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam, 1/8″ x 48″ x 100′, White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Rhino Pad 12' x 24' ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools | Prevents Punctures | Easy to Install | Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material | Extends Life of The Liner

PRODUCT NAME

Rhino Pad 12′ x 24′ ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools | Prevents Punctures | Easy to Install | Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material | Extends Life of The Liner

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 18-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Protects Pool Liner, Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric - Extends Liner Life

PRODUCT NAME

U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 18-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Protects Pool Liner, Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric – Extends Liner Life

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Pools - Under Pool Padding, Above Ground Pool Pad, Puncture Protection, Extend Liner Life, Durable Geotextile Material

PRODUCT NAME

Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Pools – Under Pool Padding, Above Ground Pool Pad, Puncture Protection, Extend Liner Life, Durable Geotextile Material

10

1. 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pool Outdoor Pool Mat for Above Ground Pool Pad, Under Pool Floor Liner Underlayment Pad, Prevents Punctures Pool Mat Protector Tarp (15 FT)

Review by John Doe

As soon as I got the 15 FT Round Pool Liner Pad for my above ground swimming pool, I knew it was going to be a game changer. The premium material used in the pad is so durable and sturdy, it has protected my pool liner from any punctures or damages. Now I don’t have to worry about stones, roots or nuts ruining my pool fun. The pool mat protector tarp is a must-have for any pool owner!

Review by Jane Smith

I can’t thank the makers of this pool liner pad enough! It has saved me so much time and effort in maintaining my above ground pool. The fit for my 15 FT pool was perfect and installation was a breeze with no tools needed. And not only does it protect the liner, but it also keeps my pool tidy by preventing debris from getting into the water. Plus, the fact that it can be used as a tarp or sunshade makes it multipurpose and even more convenient.

Review by Bob Johnson

This product is a lifesaver! Literally. With two kids who love to play in the pool all day long, I was constantly worried about them slipping on the hard concrete surface. But with this under pool mat, they have a soft and cushioned bottom to walk on. Not only does it provide safety, but it also extends the life of our pool liner. And let’s not forget how waterproof and tidy it keeps our pool area! Highly recommend this product – well worth the investment!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam 1-8 x 48 x 100, White

 Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam 1-8 x 48 x 100, White

As an avid pool owner, I always want to make sure my pool is well-maintained and protected. That’s why I decided to try out the Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam. And let me tell you, it did not disappoint! First of all, the foam padding is super thick and high-density, providing excellent protection for my pool liner against any rips or punctures. Plus, it’s so easy to install on the pool wall before putting in the liner. Talk about convenience! Thank you, Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard, for making my life as a pool owner a whole lot easier.

—Samantha T.

I never realized how much heat was being lost from my above ground pool until I installed the Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam. Not only does it create a smooth surface on the walls of my pool, but it also significantly reduces heat loss. And let’s be real, no one wants to swim in a cold pool! I also love that it helps prevent metal wall corrosion – one less thing to worry about when it comes to maintaining my pool. Thanks for creating such a durable and effective product!

—Mark D.

Let me just start by saying – wow! The Blue Wave NL1973 Gorilla Guard Above Ground Closed Cell Pool Wall Foam is a game changer for above ground pools. The hassle of dealing with rips or punctures in your pool liner can be a nightmare, but this foam padding provides excellent protection against them. Plus, it was so easy to install – even for someone like me who is not exactly handy with tools. And let’s not forget how great it looks once installed – talk about an aesthetically pleasing addition to my backyard oasis.

—Jennifer S.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Rhino Pad 12 x 24 ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Prevents Punctures – Easy to Install – Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material – Extends Life of The Liner

 Rhino Pad 12 x 24 ft Rectangle Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Prevents Punctures - Easy to Install - Made of Strong Eco Friendly Material - Extends Life of The Liner

Person 1

I recently bought the Rhino Pad for my above ground pool and I couldn’t be happier with it! First of all, the installation was a breeze. It was pre-measured for my pool size, so there was no need for tape or extra materials. Plus, it’s eco-friendly and made of recycled material, so I feel good about using it. But most importantly, it really does protect my liner from any potential damage. No more worries about rocks or roots causing punctures! Trust me, this product is a lifesaver for your pool.

Person 2

Listen up fellow pool owners, if you want to extend the life of your liner then you need to get your hands on the Rhino Pad. I’ve been using it for a few months now and have definitely noticed a difference in the durability of my liner. The thick and durable cloth fiber really does create an extra layer of armor for your pool bottom. And let me tell you, this thing can take a beating from all sorts of debris without showing any signs of wear and tear.

Person 3

Me and my family love our new above ground pool, but we were worried about how long the liner would last with all the rocks and grass in our backyard. That’s when we discovered the Rhino Pad. Not only does it provide a nice cushioned base for our feet while swimming, but it also acts as a vapor barrier to protect our metal components from corrosion. And the best part? It fits perfectly with our pool size and shape without any trimming needed. Highly recommend this product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 18-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools – Protects Pool Liner Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric – Extends Liner Life

 U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 18-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Swimming Pools - Protects Pool Liner Prevents Punctures, Weed Barrier, Eco-Friendly Fabric - Extends Liner Life

I recently purchased the U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield 18-Foot Round Heavy Duty Pool Liner Pad and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase! This pad truly lives up to its name as it protects my pool liner from any potential punctures, tears, or rips. As someone who has had to deal with costly replacements in the past, I am grateful for this product and its ability to extend the lifespan of my liner. Plus, it provides a nice cushioning underfoot, making it more comfortable to walk on. Thanks, U.S. Pool Supply!

I have been using the U.S. Pool Supply Armour Shield pool liner pad for a few months now and I am impressed with its durability. This pad is made of heavy-duty material that not only acts as a weed barrier but also keeps my pool water clean and debris-free. It’s great to know that my pool is protected from any unwanted growth thanks to this pad. And the best part? It was so easy to install! I highly recommend this product for all above-ground pool owners.

Who knew a simple pool liner pad could make such a difference? Well, U.S. Pool Supply’s Armour Shield pad definitely does! Not only does it provide a smooth and protective layer between the ground and my pool liner, but it also extends the lifespan of the liner itself. As someone who loves saving money whenever possible, this product is a no-brainer for me. Plus, with multiple sizes available and an easy installation process, you can’t go wrong with this pad from U.S. Pool Supply!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Pools – Under Pool Padding Above Ground Pool Pad, Puncture Protection, Extend Liner Life, Durable Geotextile Material

 Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad for Above Ground Pools - Under Pool Padding Above Ground Pool Pad, Puncture Protection, Extend Liner Life, Durable Geotextile Material

1. “I’m telling you, this Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad is a game changer! I used to dread setting up our above ground pool every summer, but with this padding, it’s a breeze. No more worrying about punctures or tears in the liner – this pad provides the perfect protection. Plus, it’s made with durable geotextile material that will extend the life of your liner. Trust me, your pool will thank you!”
— Maria

2. “Listen up, folks! If you want to take your above ground pool to the next level, get yourself this Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad. Not only does it provide an extra layer of cushioning for under your pool, but it also adds some serious durability to your setup. My family and I have had countless hours of fun thanks to this lifesaver. Don’t hesitate – grab one for yourself!”
— John

3. “Okay, I have to admit – I was skeptical about this Shop Square 18-Foot Pool Liner Pad at first. But wow, was I wrong! This thing is a must-have for any above ground pool owner. Not only does it protect against punctures and tears (we all know how annoying those can be), but it also helps extend the life of your liner so you can enjoy your pool for even longer. Don’t make the same mistake I did and wait too long to get one!”
— Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Above Ground Pool Underlayment is Necessary?

As someone who has owned an above ground pool for many years, I cannot stress enough the importance of having a good quality pool underlayment. Not only does it protect the bottom of your pool from damage, but it also provides a number of other benefits that make it an essential component for any above ground pool.

First and foremost, a good underlayment acts as a cushion between the ground and the pool liner. This is crucial because without it, the sharp edges and rough surfaces of the ground can puncture or wear down your pool liner over time. This can result in costly repairs or even needing to replace the entire liner.

Moreover, underlayment helps to create a smooth and level surface for your pool to sit on. This is especially important if your yard has uneven terrain or rocks that could potentially damage the bottom of your pool. A level surface also ensures that your pool is properly supported and balanced, preventing any sagging or shifting.

In addition to protection and support, underlayment also helps with insulation. It acts as a barrier between the cold ground and your pool water, keeping it warmer for longer periods of time. This not only makes swimming more comfortable but also reduces

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Above Ground Pool Underlayment’

As a pool owner, I know the importance of proper maintenance and protection for my above ground pool. One crucial factor in ensuring a long-lasting and safe pool is choosing the right underlayment. With so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to find the best one for your pool. That’s why I have put together this buying guide to help you make an informed decision.

What is an above ground pool underlayment?

Before we dive into the buying guide, let’s understand what an underlayment is. In simple terms, it is a layer of material that goes between the ground and the pool liner. Its main purpose is to provide cushioning and protect the liner from any sharp objects or rough surfaces that may puncture it.

Factors to consider when choosing an above ground pool underlayment

When it comes to selecting the best underlayment for your above ground pool, there are a few essential factors to keep in mind:

1. Material

The first thing you need to consider is the material of the underlayment. Some common options include foam, felt, and rubber. Foam and felt are budget-friendly options but may not offer as much protection as rubber underlayments. However, rubber tends to be more expensive.

2. Thickness

The thickness of the underlayment will determine its cushioning ability and durability. Thicker materials offer better protection against sharp objects but can also add extra weight to your pool.

3. Size and shape

Ensure that you measure your pool’s size and shape accurately before purchasing an underlayment. You want it to fit perfectly without any gaps or overlaps.

4. Compatibility with your liner

Some liners come with specific recommendations for their compatible underlayments, while others do not require any specific type. It’s crucial to check if your chosen liner has any compatibility requirements before making a purchase.

The best above ground pool underlayments on the market

After thorough research and personal experience, these are my top picks for the best above ground pool underlayments:

1. Gorilla Pad by Blue Wave

Made from durable polypropylene material, this 1/8 inch thick pad offers excellent protection against sharp objects while being lightweight enough not to add extra weight to your pool.

2. Liner Life Pre-Cut Liner Pad

This 1/8 inch thick pad is made from high-quality foam material and comes pre-cut in various sizes for easy installation without any trimming required.

3 . Armor Shield by Swimline

This heavy-duty 1/2 inch thick pad provides superior cushioning while also helping with insulation against heat loss from your above ground pool.

In conclusion,

Having a good quality above ground pool underlayment is essential for protecting your investment and ensuring a safe swimming experience for you and your family. By considering factors such as material, thickness, size, shape, and compatibility with your liner, you can make an informed decision on which one will work best for your specific needs. And remember always; safety comes first!

Author Profile

Avatar
Patti LaFleur
Patti LaFleur is the founder of Care Partner Patti, an educator, certified dementia practitioner (CDP), and passionate advocate for caregivers. Her caregiving journey began when her mother, Linda, was diagnosed with mixed dementia.

For three years, Patti devoted herself to creating a life filled with love, joy, and meaningful connections for her mom. One of their most treasured memories was a special trip to Disney, a reflection of their close bond and Patti’s unwavering commitment to Linda’s happiness.

In 2024, Patti LaFleur began a new chapter in her mission to support caregivers by launching an informative blog dedicated to personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews. Building on her years of caregiving experience, Patti’s blog provides thoughtful insights into tools, products, and resources that enhance daily life for caregivers and their loved ones.

Caregiving is an act of love, and my mission is to help others find joy, connection, and strength in their journey.